You should use an Individual Value Plot when:
While both represent individual data points as dots:
Shift | Supplier 1 | Supplier 2 |
1 | 9.996122047 | 21.3612898 |
1 | 12.62574265 | 16.7757814 |
1 | 11.59708641 | 19.2680117 |
1 | 12.4210514 | 21.61882075 |
1 | 13.75779483 | 14.55036061 |
1 | 16.27320778 | 19.52052386 |
1 | 14.87549121 | 23.18510389 |
An Individual Value Plot: